Rejections are a part of the writing business and we all know that.
Rarely does someone submit their first manuscript and have it purchased in an auction or a pre-empt moments after submission.
I’m sure that has happened to someone, somewhere in a parallel galaxy, but honestly that’s just not how it works.
So, we writers prepare ourselves for rejection. We tell ourselves it’s a part of the game and we even begin to look forward to the day we start getting “good” rejections instead of the form, “thanks but no thanks” crap.
We believe that “good” rejections do exist. We have to…that faith helps us move forward. And the reality is, there are good rejections. I just never truly believed until today.
Yes, today I received a “good” rejection.
My lovely and brilliant agent called it a “glowing” rejection. I think I like that better. “Glowing” Mel. (and not like nuclear waste, thank you very much)
The editor liked my voice a “great deal”. She followed that with “Mel has a wonderfully charming voice.”
Standing alone, that sounds fabulous. I wish the sentence would’ve actually read “Mel has a wonderfully charming voice and I want to buy it for ONE MILLION DOLLARS!” (sorry, had to get my Dr. Evil in there…) But, she didn’t.
I’ve reread the email several times and have to say, this is a positive rejection. There’s a rumor in the writing world that we tend to cling to and that is that once the “good” (or glowing) rejections start coming in, that an offer isn’t far behind.
Here’s to believing.
I’ll admit it stung a bit when I read the email. I’ll also admit that even though I’ve expected rejections, that I always had this fantasy where I would be the .0000000000001% of the writers who sold at auction just moments after my agent submitted.
I know that my book wasn’t right for this editor. If it was, she would’ve bought it. And somehow, knowing that helps just a little. I know my agent will sell this book. I know that because she is brilliant and I am brilliant and together, that makes us brilliance squared. There’s no way that the publishing world can ignore brilliance squared for long.
It’s just not possible.